
Nearly everyone in the crowded chambers stood, hand to heart to face the flag at the beginning of the July 10, 2007 Asheville City Council meeting. I kept my seat, as did a few others. Following that rote bow to nationalism with the Pledge of Allegiance, Mayor Bellamy gave the invocation, in the name of Jesus, beseeching a Father God to help the council "keep in mind that we are our brothers keepers." One would have to consider how "keeper," is defined to determine if that appeal to the patriarch was heeded.
Before the meeting I joined a group of 20 or so gathered in front of city hall led by the Revs. Amy Cantrell and Chrystal Cook of Zaccheaus House ministry. These advocates for the poor and immigrant of Asheville were also praying in the name of Jesus and holding various signs including DeCriminalize Homelessness Now, We Beg for Mental Health Care, Forgive us our Trespasses, and You Shall Not Oppress a Resident Alien.
"No matter what happens here tonight," Rev. Cantrell promised, "We're going to keep doing what we've been doing. We're going to feed each other. We're going to love each other. We're going to welcome each other..." The uniformed security man passing by on his way into City Hall spoke into his radio: "I'd say you'd better send reinforcements."
"The issue we are dealing with in Pritchard Park is vagrancy, not homelessness," Mayor Terry Bellamy declared, after listening to a Summary Report from the Community Forum on Homelessness presented by two out-of-town student interns and the assistant to the City Manager Lauren Bradley. The report seemed skewed to support predetermined conclusions and plans of action, particularly the idea of programming in Pritchard Park, a place that Councilman Carl Mumpower called an "island sanctuary for people who misbehave." To quote the report: "Among the most commonly cited [downtown social issues] were public drunkenness, feeding in Pritchard Park, disruptive behavior in the park and litter. Through staff contact with the Asheville Area Chamber of Commerce/Tourism Development Authority, concerns about downtown panhandling have also been raised."
"We are being exploited by a group of vagrant predatory people who are hiding behind a mask of being homeless," city councilman Carl Mumpower pronounced in his authoritative tone with characteristically smooth delivery. He rejected any ideas of park redesign. "No money until we get control."
Other council members were in general support of increased enforcement of laws and increased park programming.
Mayor Bellamy said she had observed "some who actually have a place to live in Asheville but choose to come downtown and hang out."
Imagine that!
"It is critical we address the vagrancy issues," Bellamy asserted, "and clean-up down town. Do we have more trash cans coming?" she asked. She also brought up the issue of alternative sentencing, fines, and development of a "nuisance court."
Mumpower warned, "When you come to Asheville either behave, get help or go to jail." He suggested both a work program and a tent jail. Councilman Bryan Freeborn asked for more police presence during peak use hours. The Committee formed to address issues at Pritchard Park was instructed to go forward and look at "programming and programming only." The council acknowledged the presence of certain "service providers" without acknowledging the Revs. Cantrell and Cook who were seated in the chambers.
The council then turned its attention to immigrants.
"Illegal immigration is a form of cultural terrorism," Mumpower asserted, comparing the presence of undocumented workers to the so-called "vagrants" in Pritchard Park. He called for empowerment of local police as federal agents through training under section 287G of the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). A chilling prospect, indeed. If such a request were to pass, we would provide the Asheville police with even more residents to chase: The so-called "vagrants" in our city parks, the pesky demonstrators who stand on street corners protesting crime in the highest offices of the land, and the undocumented immigrants among us. Truly, Asheville will be "our brothers' keeper" if Mr.Mumpowers'suggestion gains support. Our brother's will be kept in tent jails, or county lock-ups, or held on ICE detention awaiting deportation.
After the break, and responding to my call for clarification of just what council means by the term "vagrant," Mayor Bellamy declared that the "conversation about vagrancy was not meant to eliminate vagrants, but the illegal activities vagrants are doing." And Mr. Mumpower added, "we're not going after vagrancy, but vagrancy plus behaviors."
Then Council turned to the issue of steep slope development with the tedious charts and complex formulas presented by the planning department for slope and elevation and grading combinations. It was all too confusing for me. Heather Rayburn commented "The people making money off us not having strong regulation are the people influencing policy." She directed her comments to a businessman from the "Mountain Council for Accountable Development," or some such misnomer. Councilman Mumpower asserted "We do not own this land, it's owned by people. Its an investment in their future. ...[restrictions amount to] taking property rights away from owners to save the view for those who already have theirs." The woman seated beside me remarked, "I argue for property rights even though it kills me to see what is going on in these mountains." Its probably best to look up the Asheville Citizen-Times report to find out just what council decided on this issue.
At 10 p.m., Council chambers were still filled with "Let Asheville Vote" folks. It was a petition I gladly signed. Whatever the intention of the Democrats on council who pushed for Partisan elections, as an Independent voter I am offended by the process and the resulting burden put on third party candidates. I was interested in hearing Mr. Mumpowers presentation on the issue, just as I wanted to hear the Let Asheville Vote people speak to their concerns. Councilwoman Cape surprised me by attempting to prohibit the public from speaking on the issue, calling it "a waste of time for the community," because, she said, the City Attorney had advised "in a confidential memo," that "there is nothing we can do to change the outcome of our vote." She continued, "My understanding is that once council sets the ball in motion, there is no way to change course." As she turned to the City Attorney for backup he began stammering and mumbling. Finally saying that there is "not much guidance in this area."
Mayor Bellamy seemed confused with Councilwoman Cape's assertion. "Outside in the hall you told me you wanted to pull it," she said. The process became confused and Mr. Mumpower began presenting his Powerpoint outline of his take on why the move to partisan elections was wrong. Mayor Bellamy, attempting to make a "point of Order" went back and forth with Mumpower, who would not budge from his intent to continue with the presentation. "You're just makin' it hard for me Carl," Bellamy entreated, indicating she had not been provided a copy of the presentation prior to the meeting.
Finally, Bellamy declared "You have over-stepped my ability to defend you. I am going to rule it out of order...We have a procedure..." Mumpower still would not budge,"If you would show it to me I would be happy to adhere to it."
Bellamy's frustration was apparent in the face of an obdurate Mumpower. "your disrespect for me is obvious." she said. It was a difficult power play to observe.
Despite the high drama, the hour was late for biking home, and by the time the floor was open to the public comments on the issue I had to take my leave. One comment I did hear, from a Democratic Precinct Chair who actually seemed to favor the move to Partisan elections, seemed to speak my mind on the issue: "The process ...went too fast. It looks bad."
Those who offer their services on city council open themselves to scrutiny and criticism and are faced with complex and divisive issues. This meeting was certainly an indication of that. I hope that this city, with all the pressures of growth and development and the influx of extraordinary wealth in the midst of inexcusable social injustice, will remember the simple words of Rev. Amy Cantrell "We're going to feed each other. We're going to love each other. We're going to welcome each other..." And I hope that when we pledge our allegiance it is not to a flag under whose colors we occupy and invade other lands, but to the people who must find a way to live together; allegiance not to a nation gone astray, but to our blessed and endangered Earth.
graphic lifted